back to all posts
August 18, 2026

Why this Harvard professor says admissions Is selecting for the wrong student | Jonathan Teubner

Emily has spent years on this show saying out loud that faculty are the blockers: slow, allergic to innovation, standing in the way of anything operational. This week the other side sent a representative.

Jonathan Teubner has taught and researched on three continents (Virginia, Melbourne, fellowships in Paris and Berlin, now Harvard) and has never once sat in an admissions office. He's also co-founder and CEO of FilterLabs.AI, which means he has hired the graduates this system produces and spends his working life finding real signal underneath official narratives. He opens by calling himself an emissary from the enemy. Then he makes an argument Emily didn't see coming: the hostility she keeps running into is downstream of a recruiting war faculty never agreed to fight.

What follows is the conversation the two halves of a university almost never have out loud.

In this episode:

  • Why faculty describe themselves as "pure victims" of undergraduate admissions, and the escapism hiding inside that claim
  • What Jonathan sees in a Harvard classroom that no application file shows: students who optimized their way in and can't say what they love
  • His "outlandish prophecy" about which institutions are still standing in 20 years, and which ones accelerate their own extinction
  • Why the best hires at his AI company were history and art majors, not the people who majored in the skill
  • What every other country never built, and why "3% from the state" made him question the word public
  • The thought experiment he'd hand every enrollment leader: what if you only found 500 students this year?
  • His magic wand answer, from a man who sells technology for a living: take the devices out

How Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute partnered with CollegeVine to launch a financial aid agent that powers a deposit and melt tracker its enrollment team runs

How Roosevelt University partnered with CollegeVine to turn one enrollment pilot into a connected system of agents across financial aid, student services, and more.

Why this Harvard professor says admissions Is selecting for the wrong student | Jonathan Teubner

How to redesign a university around the students it was never built for | Brian Reed

Re-engage your fall 2026 melt students with autonomous agents

Turn insight into action with tasks

How Molloy University partnered with CollegeVine to use AI for transcript processing, giving 835 hours back to its operations team

How Barry University partnered with CollegeVine to build the foundation for consistent decisions and earlier interventions, powering its degree audit and a 24/7 student helpdesk

How Widener University partnered with CollegeVine to turn disconnected systems into a summer catch-up plan for its students

Build a course schedule you can actually defend

How Northern Arizona University partnered with CollegeVine to replace event-by-event outreach with an agent that accompanies 11,000 visiting families a year

How New Jersey Institute of Technology partnered with CollegeVine to answer students faster and build one view of the student record

EDUCAUSE Demo Day | How CollegeVine's ontology powers AI across higher ed

6 AI use cases gaining traction in higher ed operations

The VineDown: How to make enrollment management cool again | Reggie Hill @ UMSL

Introducing CollegeVine’s free IPEDS Insights Agent

Before you deploy an AI agent, ask yourself these 3 questions

How your enrollment agent turns one question into a deployed app

CollegeVine CEO Zack Perkins chats with Mickey Baines about how AI is changing enrollment analytics

Jessica Bohan and Mickey Baines talk about how higher ed teams can use AI agents

The VineDown: The subprime student loan crisis no one is talking about with New America's Stephen Burd

The VineDown: The CFO playbook for enrollment leaders with Kevin Dyerly at University of Redlands

The VineDown: Why most enrollment leaders are optimizing for the wrong number with Dr. John G. Haller

The VineDown: From basketball coach to NACAC president: Todd Rinehart on recruiting with your soul intact

The VineDown: The transcript is broken: Kevin Mathes on why admissions is running on outdated infrastructure

The VineDown: How UCLA's head of admissions processes 170,000 applications a year | Gary Clark

The VineDown: How brutal honesty built five straight years of enrollment records | Jenny Sawyer @ Louisville

The VineDown: How to expand the definition of student success with the admissions leader @ UT Austin

AI in Student Affairs?

From CBOs: The Financial Outlook for Higher Ed Report

The Campus Tech Team's Views on AI

How Finance Leaders Are Charting a Strategic Path for AI in Higher Ed

Will AI reshape the value proposition of Higher Ed?

Establishing a human baseline for transcript reading accuracy

Unlocking AI Transformation: How Finance Leaders Are Shaping the Future of Higher Ed

Higher education is asking the wrong question about AI

Critical insights at the speed of thought

Know your feeder schools before travel season

How AI agents could save your incoming class

Your enrollment briefing, ready before you sit down

How your enrollment agent learns your CRM

Introducing the communications audit

Getting ahead of summer melt

Previous Article
Next Article